Files
CherryHQ-cherry-studio/docs/references/testing/database-testing.md
槑囿脑袋 1382a8dd7c feat(knowledge): route embeddings and reranking through the AI service (#15796)
### What this PR does

Before this PR:

- Knowledge embeddings and reranking ran through the legacy
embedjs-based
knowledgeV1 stack with their own provider clients, independent of the
app's
  AI service.
- File-processing intake accepted several heterogeneous input shapes,
and
knowledge file items were tracked by FileEntry ids, coupling file
content to
  the file-manager entry/cache.

After this PR:

- Embeddings and reranking are routed through the unified `AiService`
(with
cherryin rerank support) and guarded by strict embedding-dimension
validation
  that rejects stale/mismatched vectors.
- File-processing intake is collapsed to a single path-based model;
knowledge
  file items are stored by base-relative path under the knowledge-base
directory, and v1 uploads are copied into the v2 base dir during
migration so
  migrated items stay reindexable/restorable.
- Legacy `knowledgeV1` is removed; the orchestration services were
renamed to
  `KnowledgeService` / `FileProcessingService`.
- Chat -> knowledge attach is temporarily disconnected (tracked TODO)
while the
  v2 file-manager bridge is rebuilt.

Fixes #N/A (no linked issue)

### Why we need it and why it was done in this way

Routing embeddings/rerank through `AiService` unifies provider handling
and
credentials and removes the parallel embedjs client stack and its v1
coupling.
Storing knowledge files by base-relative path (instead of FileEntry ids)
makes
each knowledge base self-contained and portable.

The following tradeoffs were made:

- A large, coordinated refactor plus a migration step that physically
copies v1
uploads into the v2 base dir, in exchange for removing the parallel
client
  stack and making bases self-contained.
- Base-relative path storage required a fail-fast/dedup strategy for
same-named
  files and a guard for blank legacy filenames.

The following alternatives were considered:

- Keeping the embedjs stack behind an adapter — rejected; perpetuates
the
  parallel client and v1 coupling.
- Keeping FileEntry-id storage — rejected; couples knowledge files to
the
  file-manager cache and blocks portability.

### Breaking changes

- `knowledgeV1` is removed. Legacy v1 knowledge data reaches v2 only
through the
  v2 migrators; there is no v1 fallback.
- The v2 knowledge HTTP API (API gateway) now returns v2-native
per-entry fields
(`embeddingModelId`, `createdAt` on base entries; `chunkId`,
`scoreKind`,
  `rank` on search results). The response envelope (`knowledge_bases`,
  `searched_bases`, `total`) is unchanged. See

`v2-refactor-temp/docs/breaking-changes/2026-06-05-knowledge-api-v2.md`.

### Special notes for your reviewer

- This branch went through several rounds of multi-agent code review.
The most
recent 6 commits address review findings: directory-import path
collisions,
migrated-file source copying + blank `relativePath` guard, addItems
rollback
error preservation, eager `document_to_markdown` output-target
validation, a
`CompletedKnowledgeBase` type guard, and breaking-changes doc
corrections.
- Chat -> knowledge attach is intentionally disconnected for now
(tracked in
  `v2-refactor-temp/docs/knowledge/knowledge-todo.md`).
- Local full `pnpm lint`/`pnpm test` was not run per the project's
review
  conventions; please rely on CI / `pnpm build:check`.

### Checklist

- [x] Branch: This PR targets the correct branch — `main` for active
development, `v1` for v1 maintenance fixes
- [x] PR: The PR description is expressive enough and will help future
contributors
- [x] Code: Write code that humans can understand and Keep it simple
- [x] Refactor: You have left the code cleaner than you found it (Boy
Scout Rule)
- [x] Upgrade: Impact of this change on upgrade flows was considered and
addressed if required
- [ ] Documentation: A user-guide update was considered and is present
(link) or not required.
- [x] Self-review: I have reviewed my own code before requesting review
from others

### Release note

```release-note
NONE
```

---------

Signed-off-by: eeee0717 <chentao020717Work@outlook.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-09 14:04:29 +08:00

9.1 KiB

Database Testing Guide

This guide covers how to write tests that exercise the SQLite data layer in the main process. It documents the unified test harness introduced alongside the v2 refactor and the idioms that replace the older hand-rolled setups.

TL;DR

For any service, handler, seeder, or migration that reads or writes SQLite, use setupTestDatabase() from @test-helpers/db. It wires a real, isolated, file-backed SQLite database into Vitest's lifecycle and exposes it through the production application.get('DbService').getDb() path. You do not need to mock @application, nor write any CREATE TABLE SQL, nor reach for the vi.mock('node:fs', importOriginal) escape hatch.

import { setupTestDatabase } from '@test-helpers/db'
import { messageService } from '@data/services/MessageService'
import { messageTable } from '@data/db/schemas/message'
import { eq } from 'drizzle-orm'

describe('MessageService', () => {
  const dbh = setupTestDatabase()

  it('persists a message', async () => {
    const msg = await messageService.create({ topicId: 't1', role: 'user', ... })
    const [row] = await dbh.db
      .select()
      .from(messageTable)
      .where(eq(messageTable.id, msg.id))
    expect(row).toMatchObject({ role: 'user' })
  })
})

What the Harness Does

On the first test in a file the harness:

  1. Creates a unique temporary directory under os.tmpdir().
  2. Opens a LibSQL file-backed database at file://<tmp>/test.db using pathToFileURL (safe on Windows too).
  3. Runs the production migrations (migrations/sqlite-drizzle/) and the project's CUSTOM_SQL_STATEMENTS (FTS5 virtual tables, triggers). The resulting schema is byte-for-byte identical to what the real app sees after DbService.onInit.
  4. Registers durable PRAGMAs (foreign_keys = ON, synchronous = NORMAL) via the patched @libsql/client setPragma() so they survive the transaction-induced connection recycle. See the "Gotchas" section.
  5. Swaps the globally-mocked DbService to hand out the real database via MockMainDbServiceUtils.setDb(). Any production code that calls application.get('DbService').getDb() now transparently hits the test DB.
  6. Asserts PRAGMA integrity_check = 'ok' and PRAGMA foreign_keys = 1.

Before every test it truncates all user tables (keeping schema and the __drizzle_migrations journal intact). FTS5 shadow tables clear through the base-table AFTER DELETE trigger cascade.

After the whole file runs it closes the client, removes the tmpdir, and resets the mocks.

When to Use the Harness

Do use it for

  • Service tests that touch SQLite (MessageService, AssistantService, …).
  • Handler integration tests where the real DB matters (e.g. temporaryChats.integration.test.ts).
  • Seeder tests.
  • Anything that exercises FK cascades, FTS5, RETURNING semantics, or transactions — because those are exactly where Drizzle-chain mocks lie.

Do NOT use it for

  • Pure logic tests (mappers, transformers, Zod schemas, pagination helpers).
  • Handler tests that only verify wiring/routing — these legitimately mock the downstream service because the assertion is about the call shape, not the DB state.
  • LibSQL client-level contract tests (pragmaReplay.test.ts) — they need direct control over the underlying client.
  • Migrator tests under src/main/data/migration/v2/migrators/__tests__/* — their mock context has been deliberately modelled to verify the migrator's orchestration logic (phase ordering, idempotency, source fallbacks). A real DB would not add coverage over what the mock already asserts.
  • Orchestration-layer service tests that mock their downstream data service (KnowledgeService, McpService) — they test coordination, not persistence.

Options

export interface TestDatabaseOptions {
  seeders?: ISeeder[]
}
  • seeders: run these after schema init. Useful for the small set of service tests that depend on seeded data (ProviderRegistryService, preset-aware flows).
setupTestDatabase({ seeders: [presetProviderSeeder] })

Migration Recipes

Removing a legacy vi.mock('@application', ...) override

- let realDb: DbType | null = null
-
- vi.mock('@application', () => ({
-   application: {
-     get: vi.fn(() => ({
-       getDb: vi.fn(() => realDb)
-     }))
-   }
- }))
-
- const { MessageService } = await import('../MessageService')
-
- describe('MessageService', () => {
-   beforeEach(async () => {
-     const client = createClient({ url: 'file::memory:' })
-     realDb = drizzle({ client, casing: 'snake_case' })
-     await initializeTables(realDb)
-   })
-   afterEach(() => { realDb = null })
- })
+ import { setupTestDatabase } from '@test-helpers/db'
+ import { messageService } from '@data/services/MessageService'
+
+ describe('MessageService', () => {
+   const dbh = setupTestDatabase()
+   // no manual setup — dbh.db is ready in every it()
+ })

Replacing mock-chain assertions with state assertions

- const values = vi.fn().mockReturnValue({ returning: vi.fn().mockResolvedValue([row]) })
- mockInsert.mockReturnValue({ values })
-
- await service.create(dto)
-
- expect(values).toHaveBeenCalledWith({
-   name: 'New Base',
-   embeddingModelId: 'embed-model',
-   ...
- })
+ const created = await service.create(dto)
+
+ expect(created.name).toBe('New Base')
+ const [row] = await dbh.db.select().from(knowledgeBaseTable)
+ expect(row.name).toBe('New Base')
+ expect(row.embeddingModelId).toBe('embed-model')

The new form is stronger: it catches DB-side constraint rewrites (snake_case column naming, NOT NULL defaults, CHECK rejections) that the mock could not see.

Anti-Patterns

Avoid all of the following when you are using the harness.

Do NOT mock @application to override DbService

The global setup already mocks @application via mockApplicationFactory(), and the harness wires the real DB through MockMainDbServiceUtils.setDb(). A test-local override would trample that wiring.

Do NOT hand-write CREATE TABLE SQL in tests

The harness runs real migrations. Hand-written schemas drift silently when the production schema evolves; real migrations fail loudly on drift.

Do NOT use describe.concurrent / test.concurrent within a harness scope

MockMainDbServiceUtils.setDb() is a module-level singleton per test file. Running sibling tests concurrently would race on that singleton and the beforeEach truncate cycle.

Do NOT nest setupTestDatabase() calls

The harness refuses nested setup with a clear error. Place a single call at the top of the outermost describe that needs a DB, or split nested describes into sibling describes.

Do NOT re-add vi.mock('node:fs', importOriginal) in test files

The global tests/main.setup.ts keeps node:fs, node:os, and node:path real now. You don't need to undo a mock that doesn't exist. If your test genuinely needs to stub a specific fs method (e.g. fs.existsSync returning a fixed value), use vi.spyOn(fs, 'existsSync') or declare a local vi.mock('node:fs', ...) with the createNodeFsMock helper from @test-helpers/mocks/nodeFsMock.

Gotchas

LibSQL transaction connection recycle

@libsql/client's transaction() releases the current connection and lazily creates a new one on the next operation. Without the project's patched setPragma() replay mechanism, per-connection PRAGMAs (like foreign_keys = ON) would silently revert after every transaction.

The harness correctly uses setPragma() to register durable settings (replayed on every reconnect), but uses one-shot client.execute() for transient settings (like temporarily toggling FK off during truncate) — otherwise the replay array would grow linearly with truncate cycles.

file: URL on Windows

A naive 'file:' + path.join(tmpdir(), 'test.db') produces an illegal URL on Windows (file:C:\path\to\db). The harness uses pathToFileURL(dbPath).href which yields file:///C:/path/to/db.

FTS5 and NULL content

searchable_text is populated by the AFTER INSERT trigger from the message's data.blocks; messages without any main_text block end up with NULL searchable_text. The FTS5 AFTER DELETE trigger then deletes using the NULL value. This is safe — truncate passes — but your FTS assertions must account for the possibility.

Truncate vs drop

beforeEach truncates user tables; it does not drop or recreate them. Tests that need to physically drop a table (e.g. rollback-on-corruption regression tests) will corrupt the harness for every subsequent test in the file. Keep those scenarios confined to their own dedicated file and avoid sharing the harness.

The Mock System

See tests/__mocks__/README.md for the broader mock catalogue. Key pieces the harness relies on:

  • @test-mocks/main/applicationmockApplicationFactory() is wired globally in tests/main.setup.ts.
  • @test-mocks/main/DbService — the global mock's MockMainDbServiceUtils is what the harness mutates to route production lookups to the real DB.
  • @test-helpers/mocks/nodeFsMock — factory for tests that need to stub node:fs locally (the global setup no longer does this).