Files
larksuite-cli/internal/core/notconfigured.go
liangshuo-1 27a2f2758b fix(config): make agent-binding hints workspace-aware and surface user-identity risks (#728)
AI agents running inside OpenClaw / Hermes were routinely creating a parallel
app via `config init --new` instead of binding to the agent's existing app,
because every "not configured" hint and several deny errors hard-coded
`config init` regardless of workspace. Once bound, the same agents could
silently grant themselves user identity (impersonation) without the user
ever seeing a risk message in chat.

Changes:

- Introduce `core.NotConfiguredError` / `NoActiveProfileError` /
  `reconfigureHint` helpers that branch on `CurrentWorkspace()`. In agent
  workspaces they point at `lark-cli config bind --help` (a help page, not
  a ready-to-run command) so AI must read the binding workflow and confirm
  identity preset with the user before acting. In local terminals they
  preserve the previous `config init --new` guidance.

- Migrate every `config init` hint that should be workspace-aware:
  RequireConfigForProfile, default credential provider, credential provider
  fallback, secret-resolve mismatch, config show, strict-mode entry-point
  errors, default-as, profile use/rename/remove, auth list, doctor's
  config_file check (which now also wraps the OS-level "no such file"
  noise into the user-shaped "not configured" message).

- Refuse `config init` when run inside an OpenClaw / Hermes workspace by
  default; add `--force-init` for the rare case the user genuinely wants
  a parallel app. Without this guard, hint fixes were undone the moment
  AI ignored them.

- Rewrite the strict-mode deny errors in cmd/auth/login.go, cmd/prune.go,
  and internal/cmdutil/factory.go. The previous "AI agents are strictly
  prohibited from modifying this setting" terminated AI reasoning while
  providing no real gate. New errors point at `config strict-mode --help`
  with the legitimate confirmation flow and explicitly note that switching
  does NOT require re-bind. Integration test envelopes updated.

- Tighten `config bind --help` and `config strict-mode --help` to encode
  the user-confirmation discipline directly: identity preset semantics
  (bot-only vs user-default), "DO NOT switch without explicit user
  confirmation", and a cross-reference clarifying that `config bind` is
  for changing the underlying app while `config strict-mode` is the
  policy-only switch (resolves an ambiguity an audit run found).

- Surface user-identity (impersonation) risk at every config write that
  newly grants it, by reusing the canonical IdentityEscalationMessage
  string from bind_messages.go:
  - `noticeUserDefaultRisk` fires on flag-mode bind landing on
    user-default, including the first-time case `warnIdentityEscalation`
    misses (it requires a previous bot lock).
  - `setStrictMode` warns when transitioning bot → user or bot → off
    (newly permits user identity); stays quiet on narrowing changes
    and on off → user (off already permitted user).

- Add tests: notconfigured_test.go (workspace branches),
  init_guard_test.go (refuse + --force-init bypass), bind_warning_test.go
  (user-default warning fires; bot-only does not), strict_mode_warning_test.go
  (5 transitions covering both warn and no-warn paths).

Two follow-ups intentionally deferred: the keychain master-key hint at
internal/keychain/keychain.go:42 still suggests `config init` because the
keychain package can't import core (would be circular); fixing requires
either parameterizing the hint via callback or extracting workspace into
its own package. The lark-shared skill doc still tells AI to run
`config init` for first-time setup; updating the skill is in scope for
a follow-up PR.

Change-Id: I02273e044d9e061d211ceaa4f3ed5a3fb28325b3
2026-05-06 19:27:24 +08:00

121 lines
4.5 KiB
Go

// Copyright (c) 2026 Lark Technologies Pte. Ltd.
// SPDX-License-Identifier: MIT
package core
import (
"errors"
"fmt"
"os"
)
// LoadOrNotConfigured wraps LoadMultiAppConfig with the standard "not yet
// configured vs. couldn't read" disambiguation that every config-required
// command should use:
//
// - file missing → workspace-aware NotConfiguredError (init / bind hint)
// - parse error / permission error → real load failure with the original
// cause preserved, so the user can actually fix the broken file
//
// Without this, every call site that did `if err != nil { return
// NotConfiguredError() }` silently coerced corrupt-config into "run init",
// which sent users in circles when their config.json was just malformed.
func LoadOrNotConfigured() (*MultiAppConfig, error) {
multi, err := LoadMultiAppConfig()
if err != nil {
if errors.Is(err, os.ErrNotExist) {
return nil, NotConfiguredError()
}
// Surface the real cause (parse error, permission denied, etc.)
// so the user can fix the broken file. Wrapping as ConfigError
// keeps it on the standard structured-envelope path at the root
// command's error sink.
return nil, &ConfigError{
Code: 2,
Type: "config",
Message: fmt.Sprintf("failed to load config: %v", err),
}
}
if multi == nil || len(multi.Apps) == 0 {
return nil, NotConfiguredError()
}
return multi, nil
}
const (
// localInitHint is the canonical "you're in a regular terminal, run
// init" guidance — shared by NotConfiguredError and NoActiveProfileError
// so the same session can't show two different recommended commands.
localInitHint = "run `lark-cli config init --new` in the background. It blocks and outputs a verification URL — retrieve the URL and open it in a browser to complete setup."
// agentBindHint is the canonical "you're in an Agent workspace, see
// the binding workflow" guidance. Always points at --help (never a
// ready-to-run bind command) so the AI reads the confirmation
// discipline (identity preset, user opt-in) before acting.
agentBindHint = "read `lark-cli config bind --help`, then ask the user to confirm intent and identity preset (bot-only or user-default); only after both are confirmed, run `lark-cli config bind`"
)
// NotConfiguredError returns the canonical "not configured" error, with a
// hint that depends on the active workspace:
//
// - WorkspaceLocal → suggest `config init --new` (creates a new app).
// - WorkspaceOpenClaw / WorkspaceHermes → point at `config bind --help`
// rather than a ready-to-run command, because binding is policy-laden:
// the user must pick an identity preset (bot-only vs user-default),
// and re-binding may overwrite an existing one. The help text walks
// the AI through the confirmation flow.
//
// All "config not loaded yet" call sites should use this helper rather than
// hand-rolling a hint, so AI agents always get a workspace-correct next step.
func NotConfiguredError() error {
ws := CurrentWorkspace()
if ws.IsLocal() {
return &ConfigError{
Code: 2,
Type: "config",
Message: "not configured",
Hint: localInitHint,
}
}
return &ConfigError{
Code: 2,
Type: ws.Display(),
Message: fmt.Sprintf("%s context detected but lark-cli is not bound to it", ws.Display()),
Hint: agentBindHint,
}
}
// reconfigureHint returns the workspace-aware "fix it from scratch" hint
// used by error paths that aren't full ConfigErrors (e.g. plain fmt.Errorf
// strings from keychain / secret validation). Local → `config init`;
// Agent → `config bind --help` so the AI reads the binding workflow and
// confirms identity preset with the user before running the actual command.
func reconfigureHint() string {
if CurrentWorkspace().IsLocal() {
return "please run `lark-cli config init` to reconfigure"
}
return agentBindHint
}
// NoActiveProfileError mirrors NotConfiguredError for the related
// "config exists but the requested profile cannot be resolved" case. In agent
// workspaces a missing profile typically means the binding was wiped while
// the workspace marker remained — re-binding is the correct fix, not init.
func NoActiveProfileError() error {
ws := CurrentWorkspace()
if ws.IsLocal() {
return &ConfigError{
Code: 2,
Type: "config",
Message: "no active profile",
Hint: localInitHint,
}
}
return &ConfigError{
Code: 2,
Type: ws.Display(),
Message: fmt.Sprintf("no active profile in %s workspace", ws.Display()),
Hint: agentBindHint,
}
}